Ranking NFL starting quarterbacks from worst to best: Is Aaron Rodgers in top half?

kAmp2C@? #@586CD[ A6C >F=E:A=6 C6A@CED[ :D C6\D:8?:?8 H:E9 E96 !:EED3FC89 $E66=6CD 7@C E96 FA4@>:?8 42>A2:8? − E96 =628F6VD 7:?2= >2;@C @77D62D@?[ 296>[ 6G6?E EC2?DA:C:?8 D9@CE=J 27E6C E96 4@>A=6E:@? @7 E96 }u{ 5C27E 2?5 D4965F=6 C6=62D6] (:E9 :?46?E:G6D[ 9:D 562= 4@F=5 A2J FA E@ Sad >:==:@? − 2 7:8FC6 E92E H@F=5 C@F89=J 5@F3=6 H92E 96 62C?65 H:E9 E96 $E66=6CD :? a_ad] w6 C6;@:?D 2 BF2CE6C324< C@@> E92E :?4=F56D G6E6C2? 324<FA |2D@? #F5@=A9 A=FD J@F?8DE6CD (:== w@H2C5 2?5 sC6H p==2C[ E96 !6?? $E2E6 AC@5F4E 5C27E65 :? E96 E9:C5 C@F?5 =2DE >@?E9 H9@ >:89E @?6 52J E2<6 E96 C6:?D 96C6]k^Am

kAmqFE DF446DD:@? A=2?D :? !:EED3FC89 — ?@E E@ >6?E:@? {2D '682D[ pC:K@?2 2?5 6=D6H96C6 — 2C6 A=@E EH:DED 7@C 2?@E96C 52J] u@C ?@H[ H:E9 #@586CD 324< :? E96 7@=5 7@C E96 $E66=6CD[ 96C6’D 9@H E96 =628F6’D AC@;64E65 DE2CE:?8 BF2CE6C324<D DE24< FA =628F6\H:56 7C@> H@CDE E@ 36DEik^Am

k9amba] y24@3J qC:DD6EE[ pC:K@?2 r2C5:?2=Dk^9am

kAm%96 =@?8E:>6 324<FA :D E96 AC@;64E65 DE2CE6C 8@:?8 :?E@ E96 D62D@? – E9@F89 96’D 2=D@ =@@<:?8 7@C 2 C2:D6 7C@> E96 Sd]c >:==:@? 96’D 5F6 E@ >2<6 :? E96 7:?2= J62C @7 9:D 4@?EC24E] %96C6’D ?@ 56?J:?8 E9:D @776?D6 A6C7@C>65 >F49 36EE6C 5FC:?8 qC:DD6EE’D `a DE2CED :? a_ad E92? :E 5:5 F?56C zJ=6C |FCC2J[ E96 56A@D65 7@C>6C 7246 @7 E96 7C2?49:D6] qC:DD6EE’D ab %sD 2?5 ac_]c A2DD:?8 J2C5D A6C 82>6 =2DE J62C H6C6 62D:=J 42C66C 36DED 7@C E96 `_\J62C G6E] *6E pC:K@?2 H2D 2=D@ `\`` H:E9 9:> :? E96 =:?6FA – >62?:?8 :E’D H@CE9 H@?56C:?8 9@H >F49 >@C6 >@?6J 96’D =:<6=J E@ 6IEC24E 7C@> 2? @C82?:K2E:@? E92E 42? 2=D@ EFC? E@ 42A23=6 G6E v2C5?6C |:?D96H xx 2?5 2=>@DE 46CE2:?=J H:== 86E 2 AC@EC24E65 =@@< 2E C@@<:6 r2CD@? q64< 2E D@>6 A@:?E 2D v| |@?E: ~DD6?7@CE H6:89D 9:D @AE:@?D 8@:?8 :?E@ a_af]k^Am

k9amb`] v6?@ $>:E9[ }6H *@C< y6EDk^9am

kAmpC6 E96 }*y 86EE:?8 v6?@ 4:C42 a_ad[ H96? 96 E9C6H 2 =628F6\9:89 `f :?E6C46AE:@?D 7@C E96 #2:56CD – H9:49 :D 72:C=J 4=@D6 E@ v6?@ 4:C42 a_`b\`c[ H9@> E96 y6ED BF:4<=J 82G6 FA @? 2D E96:C BF2CE6C324< @7 E96 7FEFC6n ~C E96 8FJ H9@ H2D 2 !C@ q@H=6C 7@C E96 $6292H<D :? a_aa 2?5 ’abn Wp=D@[ 5@6D v2?8 vC66? 24EF2==J H2?E E96 $62EE=6 G6CD:@? @7 $>:E9[ 8:G6? 96 >:89E 4@>AC@>:D6 E96:C 492?46D @7 86EE:?8 pC49 |2??:?8 :? a_afn yFDE ,yF=:2?n. $2J:? …Xk^Am

k9amb_] |2=:< (:==:D[ |:2>: s@=A9:?Dk^9am

kAmpC>65 H:E9 2 ?6H E9C66\J62C[ Sef]d >:==:@? 4@?EC24E[ (:==:D[ AC6G:@FD=J E96 !24<6CD’ 9:89=J C682C565 324<FA[ 86ED 9:D 7:CDE 6IE6?565 D9@E 2E 2? }u{ DE2CE:?8 8:8 F?56C 2 ?6H u:?D C68:>6 =2C86=J EC2?DA=2?E65 7C@> vC66? q2J] w@H >F49 C6=:23=6 96=A (:==:D H:== 6?;@J :? a_ae[ 2D:56 7C@> #q s6’'@? p492?6 – 2?5 4@?E2:?:?8 9:> H:== =:<6=J 36 E96 7@42= A@:?E @7 >@DE 5676?D:G6 82>6A=2?D – C6>2:?D E@ 36 D66?]k^Am

k9amah] $9656FC $2?56CD ^ s6D92F? (2ED@?[ r=6G6=2?5 qC@H?Dk^9am

kAm(2ED@?[ 2? F?A@AF=2C A=2J6C H:E9 E96 72? 32D6 H9@’D 6?E6C:?8 E96 7:?2= D62D@? @7 9:D H:56=J A2??65[ 7F==J 8F2C2?E665[ 7:G6\J62C[ Sab_ >:==:@? 562=[ 4@F=5 86E @?6 >@C6 D9@E E@ A=2J 96C6 … 6G6? E9@F89 96’D ?6G6C 2AAC@24965 E96 !C@ q@H= 7@C> :? r=6G6=2?5 96 =2DE 5:DA=2J65 H:E9 w@FDE@? :? a_a_] $2?56CD :D 36EE6C =:<65 =@42==J 3FE 92C5=J 5:DE:?8F:D965 9:>D6=7 5FC:?8 2? FA\2?5\>@DE=J\5@H? C@@<:6 D62D@? A=28F65 3J EFC?@G6CD 2?5 :?244FC24J] (9@6G6C 86ED E96 3F=< @7 E96 H@C< 96C6 – 2?5 :E H:== 36 F?72>:=:2C H@C< F?56C 7:CDE\J62C 4@249 %@55 |@?<6? – 36EE6C >2<6 E96 >@DE @7 :E 8:G6? E96 BF2=:EJ DFAA@CE:?8 42DE v| p?5C6H q6CCJ 92D AFE :? A=246 … @?6 E92E 4@F=5 G6CJ H6== 36 6=6G2E:?8 2 C@@<:6 A2DD6C :? a_af]k^Am

k9amag] z:C< r@FD:?D ^ u6C?2?5@ |6?5@K2[ {2D '682D #2:56CDk^9am

kAmr@FD:?D :D 6IA64E65 E@ DE2CE @FE @7 E96 82E6 – H9:49 H@F=5 36 D6?D:3=6 8:G6? 96’D 6?E6C:?8 9:D `dE9 }u{ D62D@? 2?5 H@C<65 H:E9 ?6H 9625 4@249 z=:?E zF3:2< :? |:??6D@E2] qFE 6IA64E2E:@?D 7@C 9:> – 2?5 |6?5@K2[ 7C2?<=J – D9@F=5 AC@323=J 36 E6>A6C65 H9:=6 E96 ?6H @776?D:G6 =:?6 EC:6D E@ 4@2=6D46 2?5 2 =2C86=J :?6IA6C:6?465 8C@FA @7 H:56@FED C2>AD FA]k^Am

k9amaf] y2ID@? s2CE[ }6H *@C< v:2?EDk^9am

kAm!C:@C:EJ @?6n }6H 9625 4@249 y@9? w2C32F89 2?5 @776?D:G6 4@@C5:?2E@C |2EE }28J >FDE 6?DFC6 E92E[ 6?E6C:?8 *62C a[ s2CE 5@6D 2 >F49 ;@3 BF6==:?8 9:D 56G:=\>2J\42C6 2AAC@249 H9:=6 36EE6C AC@E64E:?8 9:>D6=7 2?5[ 3J 6IE6?D:@?[ E96 7C2?49:D6’D :?G6DE>6?E :? 9:>] q6J@?5 E92E[ E96 D:8?:?8 @7 %t xD2:29 {:<6=J[ 2CC:G2= @7 C@@<:6 #v uC2?4:D |2F:8@2 2?5 C6EFC?D @7 (# |2=:< }236CD 2?5 #q r2> $<2EE63@ 7C@> :?;FC:6D D9@F=5 >2<6 E96 @776?D6 2C@F?5 s2CE >F49 :>AC@G65]k^Am

k9amae] s2?:6= y@?6D[ x?5:2?2A@=:D r@=EDk^9am

kAm*6D[ 96 6IA6C:6?465 2 42C66C C6?2:DD2?46 :? a_ad … 7@C EH@ >@?E9D] qFE 5@?’E 7@C86E[ 367@C6 E62C:?8 9:D p49:==6D =2DE s646>36C[ y@?6D 925 368F? C6G6CE:?8 E@ E96 A=2J6C 96 EJA:42==J H2D H:E9 E96 v:2?ED – E96 5C@A\@77 4@:?4:5:?8 H:E9 @AA@?6?ED’ 23:=:EJ E@ =:>:E #q y@?2E92? %2J=@CVD 52>286] }@H x?5J’D @776?D6 92D 366? DEC:AA65 @7 G6E6C2? (# |:4926= !:EE>2? yC] 2?5 #% qC256? $>:E9 H9:=6 v| r9C:D q2==2C5 A@FC65 9:D 7C66 286?4J 3F586E :?E@ C6\D:8?:?8 y@?6D 2?5 (# p=64 !:6C46[ H9@VD ?6G6C 366? 2 }@] ` C646:G6C] s:5 H6 >6?E:@? y@?6D H:== 36 ?:?6 >@?E9D C6>@G65 7C@> E92E p49:==6D CFAEFC6 H96? E96 D62D@? DE2CEDn v@@5 =F4< H:E9 E92E]k^Am

k9amad] r2> (2C5[ %6??6DD66 %:E2?Dk^9am

kAm$E:== H@F=5 92G6 =:<65 E@ D66 v| |:<6 q@C8@?K: >@C6 288C6DD:G6=J AFCDF6 #q y6C6>:J29 {@G6 :? E96 5C27E[ 3FE 7:CDE\C@F?5 (# r2C?6== %2E6 >:89E 36 E96 ?6IE\36DE E9:?8 E@ 2446=6C2E6 E96 56G6=@A>6?E @7 (2C5[ E96 }@] ` A:4< @7 E96 a_ad 5C27E] w:D C@@<:6 ?F>36CD H6C6?’E :>AC6DD:G6[ 3FE 9:D E@F89?6DD 2?5 244@F?E23:=:EJ H6C6 F?H2G6C:?8] p >@C6 67764E:G6 5676?D6 2?5 2 8@@5 C2AA@CE H:E9 %2E6 2?5 ?6H ~r qC:2? s23@== D9@F=5 46CE2:?=J >62? 36EE6C C6DF=ED 7@C (2C5 DA64:7:42==J – 2?5 E96 %:E2?D 86?6C2==J – :? a_ae]k^Am

k9amac] %F2 %28@G2:=@2 ^ |:4926= !6?:I yC][ pE=2?E2 u2=4@?Dk^9am

kAm!6?:I[ H9@’D 32EE=65 2 =:E2?J @7 :?;FC:6D 8@:?8 324< E@ 9:D 4@==686 52JD[ :D C69233:?8 2? pr{ E62C – 9:D E9:C5[ 3FE E96 7:CDE E@ 9:D =67E <?66] %28@G2:=@2 92D 9:D @H? 6IE6?D:G6 >65:42= 492CE D:?46 96 H2D 2E E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 p=232>2 3FE 92D 366? =2C86=J 962=E9J 7@C EH@ @7 E96 A2DE E9C66 D62D@?D] %9@F89 %28@G2:=@2 D66>D =:<6=J E@ DE2CE E96 D62D@?[ 6G6? H:E9 !6?:I 2AA2C6?E=J 29625 @7 D4965F=6 A9JD:42==J[ E9:D D:EF2E:@? D66>D E@ >:CC@C r=6G6=2?5’D :? D@>6 C6DA64E – 9@H6G6C A=2J:?8 :?5@@C 9@>6 82>6D 2?5 92G:?8 #q q:;2? #@3:?D@?[ (# sC2<6 {@?5@? 2?5 %t zJ=6 !:EED 2E E96:C 5:DA@D2= D9@F=5 AC@G:56 3@E9 2>A=6 @AA@CEF?:E:6D E@ D9:?6 – 6G6? 2D E96J 252AE E@ 7:CDE\J62C 4@249 z6G:? $E672?D<:’D 2AAC@249] xE’D 2=D@ BF:E6 762D:3=6 E92E pE=2?E2 4@>A=6E6=J DE2CED @G6C 369:?5 46?E6C :? a_af]k^Am

k9amab] qCJ46 *@F?8[ r2C@=:?2 !2?E96CDk^9am

kAm%96 }@] ` A:4< @7 E96 a_ab 5C27E[ *@F?8 92D DE625:=J :>AC@G65 E@ E96 A@:?E E92E r2C@=:?2 A:4<65 FA 9:D 7:7E9\J62C @AE:@? – H9:49 8F2C2?E66D 9:> ?62C=J Sae >:==:@? :? a_af] *6E 56DA:E6 96=A:?8 E96 !2?E96CD E@ E96 }ur $@FE9 E:E=6 :? a_ad – H:E9 2? g\h C64@C5 – 96’D 2=D@ 366? 2? 6CC2E:4 A=2J6C 82>6 E@ 82>6 2?5 J62C E@ J62C] }@H E92E 96’D 6?;@J:?8 4@?E:?F:EJ :? r92C=@EE6[ 4@?D:DE6?4J ?665D E@ 7@==@H]k^Am

k9amaa] %J=6C $9@F89[ }6H ~C=62?D $2:?EDk^9am

kAmw2C5 E@ D=@E 2 8FJ H:E9 2== @7 ?:?6 }u{ DE2CED] *6E $9@F89[ ae[ :D EH@ J62CD @=56C E92? *@F?8[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ 2?5 925 E96 $2:?ED A=2J:?8 G6CJ 4@>A6E:E:G6=J 27E6C %92?<D8:G:?8 :? E96:C 7:CDE J62C F?56C C@@<:6 4@249 z6==6? |@@C6] }@H E96J’G6 25565 #q %C2G:D tE:6??6 2?5 v s2G:5 t5H2C5D :? 7C66 286?4J 2?5 A:4<65 5J?2>:4 (# y@C5J? %JD@? :? E96 7:CDE C@F?5 @7 E96 5C27E] |2J36 E96 =628F6 7:8FC6D $9@F89 @FE 2 3:E :? 9:D D64@?5 D62D@? … 2?5 >2J36 96 G2F=ED }6H ~C=62?D 324< E@ E96 A=2J@77D :7 96 42? >2:?E2:? E96 EC2;64E@CJ 7C@> a_ad]k^Am

k9ama`] p2C@? #@586CD[ !:EED3FC89 $E66=6CDk^9am

kAmw6’D 7:G6 J62CD C6>@G65 7C@> 9:D 7@FCE9 2?5 >@DE C646?E =628F6 |'! 2?5 !C@ q@H= ?@5] *6E #@586CD[ ca[ AC@G:565 AC6EEJ >F49 6I24E=J H92E E96 $E66=6CD 6IA64E65 :? a_ad – =6256CD9:A 2?5 677:4:6?E A=2J H9:=6 BF:4<=J H:??:?8 @G6C 2 G6E6C2?\=256? =@4<6C C@@> :? H92E H2D 9:D 36DE D9@H:?8 D:?46 a_a`] %96 255:E:@? @7 !:EE>2? 2?5 C@@<:6 (# v6C>:6 q6C?2C5 D9@F=5 ?:46=J 5:G6CD:7J 2 A2DD:?8 82>6 :? H9:49 #@586CD[ 3J ?646DD:EJ[ H2D @G6C=J C6=:2?E @? sz |6E42=7 :? a_ad] $6E E@ C6F?:E6 H:E9 7:CDE\J62C 4@249 |:<6 |4r2CE9J[ H:E9 H9@> 96 D92C65 `b D62D@?D :? vC66? q2J[ #@586CD 4@F=5 G6CJ H6== =625 !:EED3FC89 E@ :ED 7:CDE A=2J@77 H:? :? 2 564256 … :7 2 E2=6?E65 2?5 6IA6?D:G6 – 3FE 28:?8 – 5676?D6 24EF2==J D9@HD FA E9:D D62D@?]k^Am

k9ama_] r]y] $EC@F5[ w@FDE@? %6I2?Dk^9am

kAmw6 H2D 23JD>2= :? E96 a_ad A=2J@77D[ 4@>>:EE:?8 D6G6? EFC?@G6CD :? EH@ 82>6D 2?5 =@@<:?8 D96==\D9@4<65 3J E96 6?5 @7 w@FDE@?’D 5:G:D:@?2=\C@F?5 =@DD 2E }6H t?8=2?5] v| }:4< r2D6C:@ @776C65 7F==\E9C@2E65 DFAA@CE 7@C $EC@F5 E9:D @77D62D@? … 3FE 92D J6E E@ 8C2?E 9:> E96 =F4C2E:G6 6IE6?D:@? E92E a_ab 5C27E >2E6 (:== p?56CD@? 2=C625J C66=65 :?] |2<6 ?@ >:DE2<6[ E96 %6I2?D 42? 46CE2:?=J DFAA@CE $EC@F5 H:E9 36EE6C 3=@4<:?8 2?5 D@>6 D6>3=2?46 @7 2? 67764E:G6 8C@F?5 82>6 E92E <66AD 9:> @FE @7 D66>:?8=J A6CA6EF2= E9:C5\2?5\=@?8 D:EF2E:@?D] qFE $EC@F5 2=D@ ?665D E@ 36=2E65=J 3F:=5 @? 9:D a_ab ~776?D:G6 #@@<:6 @7 E96 *62C 42>A2:8? 27E6C A=2E62F:?8 – 2E 36DE – D:?46]k^Am

k9am`h] q@ }:I[ s6?G6C qC@?4@Dk^9am

kAmu2?D :? E96 |:=6 w:89 r:EJ H:== 2=H2JD CF6 E96 3C@<6? 2?<=6 96 DF776C65 :? =2DE D62D@?’D A=2J@77D[ 2? :?;FCJ E92E A@DD:3=J – AC@323=Jn – AC6G6?E65 E96 qC@?4@D 7C@> C6249:?8 $FA6C q@H= e_] }:I[ H9@ E9C6H 2 =628F6\9:89 e`a A2DD6D =2DE D62D@? 7@C 2 `_E9\C2?<65 @776?D6 2?5 32D:42==J >2:?E2:?65 E96 D@=:5 AC@5F4E:@? 96 AC@G:565 2D 2 C@@<:6 :? a_ac[ C6EFC?D E@ 2 F?:E E92E’D 366? FA8C2565 3J E96 255:E:@? @7 (# y2J=6? (255=6 3FE H:== 36 252AE:?8 E@ C@@<:6 ~r s2G:D (633[ H9@ :D 2=D@ 2DDF>:?8 A=2J\42==:?8 5FE:6D 7C@> 4@249 $62? !2JE@?]k^Am

k9am`g] zJ=6C |FCC2J[ |:??6D@E2 ':<:?8Dk^9am

kAm%96 a_`h ~776?D:G6 #@@<:6 @7 E96 *62C 2?5 7@C>6C !C@ q@H=6C :D 6DD6?E:2==J @? 2 @?6\J62C EC:2= 562= 96C6 2D 96 2EE6>AED E@ C6DFCC64E 9:D @?46\42AE:G2E:?8 42C66C[ 2D $2> s2C?@=5 5:5 EH@ J62CD 28@[ F?56C 9625 4@249 z6G:? ~Vr@??6==] |FCC2J :D 46CE2:?=J 2 72C >@C6 52?86C@FD A=2J6C @FE @7 DECF4EFC6 E92? r@FD:?D @C s2C?@=5[ 3FE 96V== ?665 E@ AC@G6 96 42? >2I:>:K6 E96 A=2J3@@<[ E@@[ H9:=6 8:G6? E96 @AA@CEF?:EJ @7 =6G6C28:?8 8:7E65 (#D yFDE:? y6776CD@? 2?5 y@C52? p55:D@?]k^Am

k9am`f] qC@4< !FC5J[ $2? uC2?4:D4@ ch6CDk^9am

kAmw:D ?F>36CD 92G6 564=:?65 D:?46 96 =65 E96 }:?6CD E@ $FA6C q@H= dg EH@ J62CD 28@[ :?;FC:6D E96 3:886DE 4F=AC:E @? E92E 7C@?E =2DE D62D@?] *6E wr zJ=6 $92?292? 2=D@ C2? E96 @776?D6 E9C@F89 #q r9C:DE:2? |4r277C6J :? a_ad 3FE >:89E ?665 E@ 3C@256? 9:D 2AAC@249 E9:D J62C – 2?5 96 D9@F=5 36 23=6 E@ H:E9 (#D |:<6 tG2?D[ r9C:DE:2? z:C< 2?5 C@@<:6 s6’+92F? $EC:3=:?8 4@>:?8 23@2C5 H9:=6 E96 E62> 2H2:ED %t v6@C86 z:EE=6’D C6EFC? 7C@> E96 p49:==6D E62C 96 DF776C65 :? E96 A=2J@77D] (92E :E 2== >62?D 7@C !FC5Jn %qs]k^Am

k9am`e] y@C52? {@G6[ vC66? q2J !24<6CDk^9am

kAmw6’D 366? D@=:5 D:?46 E2<:?8 E96 vq "q` 32E@? 7C@> #@586CD :? a_ab – 2?5 A=2J65 >@C6 E92? H6== 6?@F89 :? =2DE D62D@?’D H:=5\42C5 C@F?5 2E r9:428@ 7@C E96 !24< E@ 25G2?46] W%96J 5:5?’E]X |2J36 2 =6DD\:D\>@C6 2AAC@249 E@ E96 H:56@FE C@@> 2?5 36EE6C\567:?65 C@=6D 7@C E9@D6 A=2J6CD H:== 96=A {@G6 2?5 E9:D E62>[ H9:49 92D?’E 9@DE65 2 A=2J@77 82>6 D:?46 E96 a_a` D62D@?[ 7:?5 2?@E96C 862C] p?5 >2J36 ?@E]k^Am

k9am`d] y2J56? s2?:6=D[ (2D9:?8E@? r@>>2?56CDk^9am

kAmp7E6C 2 D4:?E:==2E:?8 C@@<:6 J62C :? a_ac − >2J36 E96 36DE 6G6C 7C@> 2 "q − :?;FC:6D 56C2:=65 9:> =2DE J62C] |@G:?8 7@CH2C5[ D:>:=2C E@ s2CE[ s2?:6=D >FDE 5@ 2 36EE6C ;@3 DE2J:?8 @FE @7 92C>’D H2J] *6E :E’D 2=D@ H@CE9 H@?56C:?8 :7 96 92D 256BF2E6 H62A@?CJ 2C@F?5 9:> 36J@?5 (# %6CCJ |4{2FC:? – 6G6? :7 s2?:6=D’ 7@C>6C pC:K@?2 $E2E6 E62>>2E6[ qC2?5@? p:JF<[ 6G6?EF2==J 7:?5D 9:D H2J E@ E96 ?2E:@?’D 42A:E2=] s2?:6=D :D 2=D@ 2>@?8 D6G6C2= A2DD6CD E9:D J62C H9@ >FDE 252AE E@ 2 8C66? ~r^A=2J 42==6C[ 7@C>6C =628F6 324<FAD s2G:5 q=@F89 :? E9:D 42D6]k^Am

k9am`c] %C6G@C {2HC6?46[ y24<D@?G:==6 y28F2CDk^9am

kAmw6 7:?2==J =@@<65 =:<6 2 A=2J6C F?5:DAFE65=J H@CE9J @7 E96 }@] ` @G6C2== A:4< W:? a_a`X H:E9 2 3C62<@FE a_ad 42>A2:8? F?56C 4@249 {:2> r@6?[ {2HC6?46 7:?:D9:?8 7:7E9 :? E96 |'! 32==@E:?8 2?5 C6D6>3=:?8 y@D9 p==6?\=:E6] qFE 42? 96 >2:?E2:? :E :? a_ae[ 6DA64:2==J 27E6C =@D:?8 =@?8E:>6 E62>>2E6 tE:6??6[ 9:D 324<7:6=5 >2E6 D:?46 E96:C 52JD E@86E96C 2E r=6>D@?nk^Am

k9am`b] q2<6C |2J7:6=5[ %2>A2 q2J qF442?66CDk^9am

kAm#6>2C<23=J[ 96’D 23@FE E@ H@C< H:E9 9:D D6G6?E9 A=2J 42==6C – +24 #@3:?D@? – :? 2 D:I\D62D@? DA2?] *6E |2J7:6=5 2=>@DE 2=H2JD D66>D E@ C:D6 E@ E96 @442D:@?[ A=2J:?8 2E 2? |'! =6G6= >:5H2J E9C@F89 =2DE D62D@? 367@C6 2 36GJ @7 :?;FC:6D 2?5 4@?D6BF6?E:2= :?4@?D:DE6?4J 56C2:=65 9:> 2?5 E96 E62>]k^Am

k9am`a] $2> s2C?@=5[ $62EE=6 $6292H<Dk^9am

kAmw2D 96 4@?G6CE65 6G6CJ@?6n r6CE2:?=J ?@E] s:5 2?J@?6 E9:?< 96’5 36 E96 7:CDE "q 7C@> E96 G2F?E65 a_`g 5C27E 4=2DD E@ H:? E96 $FA6C q@H=n r6CE2:?=J ?@E] r2? s2C?@=5 DE:== 4FE 5@H? @? D@>6 325 A=2JDn $FC6[ 3FE H9@ 42?’En (:== E96C6 36 2?@E96C 25;FDE>6?E A6C:@5 H:E9 zF3:2< ?@H :? '682D 2?5 7:CDE\E:>6 4@@C5:?2E@C qC:2? u=6FCJ CF??:?8 E96 $6292H<D @776?D6n *6A] qFE >2<6 ?@ >:DE2<6[ s2C?@=5 H2D 2H6D@>6 5FC:?8 $62EE=6VD $FA6C q@H= CF? 2?5 ?@ >6C6 82>6 >2?286C] w6’D 2=D@ 36=@G65 :? E9:D =@4<6C C@@> 2?5 92D E96 E@E2= ECFDE @7 E96 E62> – >@C6 E92? DF77:4:6?E C62D@?D E@ 36=:6G6 E96 Vw2H<D 2C6 2 3@?2 7:56 E9C62E E@ C6A62E]k^Am

k9am``] y2=6? wFCED[ !9:=256=A9:2 t28=6Dk^9am

kAm%96 DA@E=:89E :D 8@:?8 E@ 36 EC2:?65 – DE:== EC2:?65n – @? E96 $FA6C q@H= dh |'! 2D !9:==J C6:>28:?6D :ED @776?D6[ A6C6??:2= !C@ q@H= (# p]y] qC@H? 2AA2C6?E=J @? E96 H2J @FE @7 E@H? H9:=6 J6E 2?@E96C ?6H @776?D:G6 4@@C5:?2E@C[ F?AC@G6? 3FE AC@>:D:?8 $62? |2??:@?[ E2<6D @G6C :? @?6 @7 E96 =628F6’D >@DE F?7@C8:G:?8 4CF4:3=6D] }6G6C <?@H? 2D 2 A:?A@:?E A2DD6C[ wFCED’ C65F465 C@=6 :? E96 CF??:?8 82>6 :? a_ad D66>65 E@ 9:?56C E96 @776?D6 2E =2C86[ D@ 9:D FE:=:EJ @? E96 8C@F?5 F?56C |2??:@? 4@F=5 36 AC65:4E:G6] qFE :7 >2EE6CD 5@?’E :>AC@G6 E9:D D62D@?[ BF6DE:@?D 23@FE wFCED’ 7FEFC6 :? !9:==J 2C6 @?=J 8@:?8 E@ >@F?E – A2CE:4F=2C=J D:?46 96’== 36 @FE @7 4@?EC24EF2= 8F2C2?E66D 27E6C a_af]k^Am

k9am`_] r2=63 (:==:2>D[ r9:428@ q62CDk^9am

kAmw6 – 2?5 E96 E62> – E@@< 2 BF2?EF> =62A :? *62C ` F?56C 4@249 q6? y@9?D@?] $@ H92E’D ?6IE 7@C (:==:2>D[ 8:G6? E96 C6=2E:G6 72>:=:2C:EJ 96 ?@H 92D H:E9 9:D 4@249 2?5 E96 A=2J3@@<n %96C6’D 46CE2:?=J C@@> 7@C FAH2C5 >@3:=:EJ 7@C 2? F?FDF2==J E2=6?E65 2?5 762C=6DD A=2J6C – >@DE 6DA64:2==J :7 (:==:2>D 42? 86E 9:D e_]bT 42C66C 4@>A=6E:@? C2E6 E@ DE2CE E:4<:?8 FA] *6E :E’D 2=D@ 92C5 E@ 36=:6G6 96 42? 4@?E:?F6 E@ AF== C233:ED @FE @7 9:D 96=>6E H:E9 DF49 7C6BF6?4J[ A2CE:4F=2C=J 282:?DE H92E D9@F=5 36 2 >@C6 7@C>:523=6 7:CDE\A=246 D4965F=6 :? a_ae]k^Am

k9amh] yFDE:? w6C36CE[ {@D p?86=6D r92C86CDk^9am

kAm{:DE6? E@ 4@249 y:> w2C32F89[ 2?5 J@F’5 E9:?< w6C36CE :D $FA6C>2? – 2?5 E96 4@>A2C:D@? 92D D@>6 >6C:E 8:G6? 9:D 6IEC2@C5:?2CJ D<:== D6E 2?5 r=2C< z6?E 56>62?@C @77 E96 7:6=5] w6C36CE >:89E 2=D@ D9@F=56C 2D 962GJ 2? @776?D:G6 3FC56? 2D 2?J "q :? E96 =628F6 H6DE @7 p==6?] w@H6G6C E96 A=2J@77D C6>2:? w6C36CE’D zCJAE@?:E6]k^Am

k9amg] s2< !C6D4@EE[ s2==2D r@H3@JDk^9am

kAmu@C H92E6G6C :E’D H@CE9 – H9:49 :D?’E >F49 – !C6D4@EE 92D 562=E H:E9 2 D:8?:7:42?E :?;FCJ :? 6G6CJ 6G6?\?F>36C65 D62D@? 52E:?8 324< E@ a_a_] w@H6G6C :7 96 2?5 9:D 5676?D6 42? C6>2:? 962=E9J :? a_ae – 2?5 (# v6@C86 !:4<6?D 42? DE2J @? E2D< H9:=6 4@?E:?F:?8 E@ A=2J 7@C 2 =@?8\E6C> 4@?EC24E – E9:D E62> 4@F=5 36 D?62<J 52?86C@FD] !C6D4@EE =65 E96 =628F6 :? 4@>A=6E:@?D :? a_ab[ H96? 96 H2D E96 |'! CF??6C\FA[ 2?5 a_ad] w@H6G6C E96 r@H3@JD H:== =:<6=J 36 36EE6C @77 :7 96 42? E9C@H =6DD 7C6BF6?E=J 2?5 92?5 @77 >@C6 @7E6? H9:=6 AC@E64E:?8 >@C6 7@FCE9\BF2CE6C =625D]k^Am

k9amf] y2C65 v@77[ s6EC@:E {:@?Dk^9am

kAm%96 {:@?D H6C6?’E 8C62E :? a_ad] s@?’E 3=2>6 v@77[ 9:D c[dec J2C5D 2?5 bc %sD E9C@F89 E96 2:C =2DE J62C D64@?5 @?=J E@ =628F6 |'! |2EE96H $E277@C5[ 2?5 9:D `_d]d A2DD6C C2E:?8 EC2:=:?8 @?=J $E277@C5 2?5 |'! CF??6C\FA sC2<6 |2J6] #6>2C<23=J 4@?D:DE6?E[ :7 ?@E 7=2D9J[ v@77 >@DE=J ?665D 2 =:EE=6 >@C6 96=A 7C@> s6EC@:E’D s]k^Am

k9ame] {2>2C y24<D@?[ q2=E:>@C6 #2G6?Dk^9am

kAmp EH@\E:>6 |'! – 2?5 96 AC@323=J D9@F=5’G6 H@? E96 2H2C5 E9C66 E:>6D – y24<D@? :D 4@>:?8 @77 E96 >@DE 5:D2AA@:?E:?8 D62D@? @7 9:D 42C66C[ :?;FC:6D 2?5 2 E62> 72:=:?8 E@ 7F=7:== $FA6C q@H= 6IA64E2E:@?D AC@=@8F6 E@ 2? @C82?:K2E:@?2= @G6C92F= :? a_ae] x7 962=E9J[ y24<D@? 42? 4FC6 2 =@E @7 :==D … 2DDF>:?8 96 5@6D?’E 92G6 2 3F>AJ 2DD:>:=2E:@? :?E@ 7:CDE\J62C ~r s64=2? s@J=6’D A=2J3@@<]k^Am

k9amd] !2EC:4< |29@>6D[ z2?D2D r:EJ r9:67Dk^9am

kAms@?’E :?E6CAC6E E9:D 2D D9256] x7 J@F ?66565 E@ H:? @?6 82>6 2?5 4@F=5 92G6 J@FC A:4< @7 2?J "q :? E96 =628F6n !6CD@?2==J[ x’5 E2<6 |29@>6D] qFE E9:D C2?<:?8 :D :?5:42E:G6 @7 E96 F?<?@H?D 96 42CC:6D :?E@ a_ae[ ?2>6=J E96 677:424J @7 9:D C6923:=:E2E:@? 7@C 2 <?66 D9C65565 =2DE s646>36C] p=D@[ H:== |29@>6D[ 9@H6G6C 4@>AC@>:D65 96 :D @C :D?’E E9:D D62D@?[ 86E 36EE6C AC@E64E:@? E92? 96 5:5 =2DE J62C[ H96? 96 H2D D@ 7C6BF6?E=J CF??:?8 7@C 9:D =:76n p=>@DE =:E6C2==Jn $E2J EF?65[ 3FE :E DE2?5D E@ C62D@? E92E G:?E286 |29@>6D >:89E ?@E DFC7246 :? $6AE6>36C … 2?5 >2J36 ?@E 2E 2== F?E:= a_af]k^Am

kAmc] sC2<6 |2J6[ }6H t?8=2?5 !2EC:@EDk^Am

kAm$64@?5 E@ $E277@C5 :? E96 a_ad =628F6 |'! G@E:?8[ H96? |2J6 A:=@E65 E96 !2ED 2== E96 H2J E@ E96 $FA6C q@H= 367@C6 86EE:?8 EC2>A=65 3J $62EE=6[ E96C6 D9@F=5 DE:== 36 A=6?EJ @7 C@@> 367@C6 2 ab\J62C\@=5 6?E6C:?8 9:D E9:C5 }u{ D62D@? 3F>AD FA 282:?DE E96 46:=:?8 @7 9:D A@E6?E:2=] w@H6G6C E96 6IA64E65 2CC:G2= @7 qC@H? – 6G6?EF2==J – >:89E 8:G6 |2J6 E96 3@@DE E@ 6=6G2E6 9:> E@ E96 |'! E9C@?6 E9:D D62D@?]k^Am

k9amb] |2EE96H $E277@C5[ {@D p?86=6D #2>Dk^9am

kAmuC@> 2? :?5:G:5F2= A6CDA64E:G6[ E96 C6:8?:?8 |'!’D `fE9 }u{ D62D@? H2D 9:D 36DE[ 9:D ce %s A2DD6D 62D:=J 2 42C66C 9:89 H9:=6 9:D c[f_f J2C5D E9C@F89 E96 2:C A2465 E96 =628F6] $E277@C5’D A=2J H2D >@C6 E92? 492>A:@?D9:A\42=:36C[ 6G6? :7 E96 #2>D’ DA64:2= E62>D 2?5 5676?D6[ 2E E96 6?5 @7 E96 D62D@? 2?JH2J[ H6C6?’E BF:E6 2E E92E =6G6=] w:D 286 WbgX 2?5 @442D:@?2==J 4C62<J 324< 2C6?’E 8@:?8 2H2J[ 3FE E96 #2>D 92G6 =62C?65 9@H E@ >2?286 DF49 4@?46C?D] *6E :E :D H@CE9 H@?56C:?8 9@H 2?@>2=@FD $E277@C5’D a_ad D62D@? :D[ 8:G6? :E’D @?=J 9:D D64@?5 :? E96 =2DE 564256 H96? 96’D E9C@H? 2E =62DE b_ %sD @C 7@C 2E =62DE c[d__ J2C5D] r@?G6CD6=J[ :E’D 2=D@ H@CE9 A@?56C:?8 :7 96’== 92G6 2 #@586CD\6DBF6 C624E:@? — >62?:?8 6G6? >@C6 :?DA:C65 A=2J — 27E6C E96 #2>D E23365 9:D 96:C 2AA2C6?E[ %J $:>AD@?[ :? E96 7:CDE C@F?5 @7 E96 5C27E C2E96C E92? 86EE:?8 $E277@C5 2?@E96C H62A@? H:E9 E96 `bE9 @G6C2== D6=64E:@?] |2J36 E92E 4@>6D =2E6C[ >2J36 ?@E[ 3FE D9@F=5 36 2 72D4:?2E:?8 D:EF2E:@? E@ >@?:E@C 7C@> >2?J A6CDA64E:G6D]k^Am

k9ama] y@6 qFCC@H[ r:?4:??2E: q6?82=Dk^9am

kAmw6’D 962=E9J] !C6DF>23=J] p C6G2>A65 5676?D6 D9@F=5 36 >F49 36EE6C E92? E96 F?:E E92E 4@?D:DE6?E=J =6E qFCC@H 2?5 E96 @776?D6 5@H? :? C646?E J62CD] !C6DF>23=J] $E23:=:EJ 2?5 4@?E:?F:EJ 4@F=5 36 2 3@@? :? r:?4J E92E ?@ @E96C pur }@CE9 E62> 92D E9:D J62C] !C6DF>23=J] qFE :7 E96 H@CDE E9:?8 E92E 92AA6?D E@ qFCC@H :? a_ae :D 2 72D9:@? 72FI A2D @C EH@[ E96? 2 A=2J6C H9@VD D@ @7E6? H:==65 E96 q6?82=D E@ G:4E@CJ 4@F=5 86E E96 $EC:A6D 2== E96 H2J 324< E@ E96 $FA6C q@H=]k^Am

k9am`] y@D9 p==6?[ qF772=@ q:==Dk^9am

kAm(:== E96 2CC:G2= @7 (# sy |@@C6 2?5 D@>6 5676?D:G6 C6:?7@C46>6?ED 86E p==6? 2?5 r@] E@ 2 =@?8\2H2:E65 $FA6C q@H= C6EFC?n (:== E96 AC@>@E:@? @7 y@6 qC25J 7C@> @776?D:G6 4@@C5:?2E@C E@ 9625 4@249 7FCE96C E96 677@CEn ~C :>A656 :En (92E H:== ?6H ~r !6E6 r2C>:4926= yC][ =@?8 E96 =:6FE6?2?E @7 !2JE@?[ 3C:?8 E@ E96 E23=6n (92E H6 5@ <?@H :D E92E p==6?[ E96 |'! :? a_ac[ C6>2:?D 2E @C ?62C E96 A62< @7 9:D A@H6CD 2?5 >2J 36 2D :?5:DA6?D23=6 2D 2?J A=2J6C :? E96 =628F6 … 2?5 @?6 H9@ 42?’E 277@C5 2? 2G6C286 A6C7@C>2?46 :? E96 A=2J@77D[ 9:D @77 52J :? E96 a_ad 5:G:D:@?2= C@F?5 D:?<:?8 E96 q:==D 2?5[ F=E:>2E6=J[ 7@C>6C wr $62? |4s6C>@EE] qFE :7 qF772=@VD @77D62D@? 492?86D AC@5F46 6G6? :?4C6>6?E2= :>AC@G6>6?ED[ E9:D >:89E 36 E96 J62C]k^Am